c/bbq-pitmasters

Brisket bark changed my mind about butcher paper after a 14 hour cook

I always wrapped in foil because that's what my uncle taught me. Last Saturday I ran out of foil halfway through and had to grab some butcher paper from the shed. The bark came out way better, actually crunchy instead of that soft steamed mess. I thought paper would dry it out but it held moisture fine at 225 for the last 5 hours. Anyone else find that paper only works if you wait until the stall passes 170?

0 comments

nelson.finley•16d ago

Pro tip: never trust a brisket that talks back on a Tuesday

Last Tuesday in Austin I was babysitting a 14 pound packer on my offset and it somehow hissed at me through the grate like a deflating tire, which I blamed on a loose chimney cap until I pulled it off and found a fat drip igniting on the firebox hinge, and has anyone else had a smoker make noise that sounds oddly human when the temp swings?

0 comments

linda_butler28•17d ago

That brisket stall nightmare at my first competition cook

I signed up for a backyard comp in Austin last month and hit a wall with my brisket. Internal temp sat at 156 for almost four hours, way past the usual stall time. I kept opening the smoker to check, which made things worse and cost me precious heat. Finally figured out my cheap probe was reading wrong, the actual temp was higher than I thought. Swapped to a digital thermometer and it jumped to 165 within minutes. That whole ordeal took around six hours total before I got it wrapped. Has anyone else had a bad probe throw off their whole cook timeline?

1 comments

black.margaret•18d ago

My propane tank gauge lied to me at the worst cook

Last Saturday I was 6 hours into a 14 hour brisket cook for my nephew's graduation party. The needle on my tank gauge was still in the green, so I figured I had plenty. Then I went to check the temp and the flame was out. Tank was bone dry. I had to run to the gas station at 11pm with a spare tank, but the brisket sat at 145 degrees for almost an hour. Have any of you switched to a digital scale or weight method to avoid this? I'm thinking about buying a used one off Craigslist.

1 comments

tylerw72•19d ago

Hit 212 degrees on my brisket and the stall just gave up

Been fighting a stubborn flat that sat at 198 for over an hour in my offset, so I wrapped it in butcher paper and bumped the firebox up to 300. It jumped straight to 212 in 20 minutes and came out way softer than my usual overnight cook. Anyone else see a big jump like that once you crack the stall with a hot wrap?

1 comments

ivan_hayes29•20d ago

I finally tested that 30 second rest rule my uncle swore by, total game changer for ribs

My uncle has been doing comp BBQ for like 15 years up in Kansas City. He kept telling me to rest ribs exactly 30 seconds after pulling them off, no more no less. I thought he was nuts. Last weekend I did a side by side with two racks from the same pig. One rested 30 seconds, one for 10 minutes like I always did. The 30 second one had way more bark left, and the juices stayed in. The 10 minute one was still good but the surface got all mushy and the rub washed off. He was right. Has anyone else tried a real short rest on ribs or is this just a comp thing that doesn't translate to backyard cooking?

1 comments

susanh46•20d ago

Old offset smoker taught me a cheap trick for steady temps

My 20 year old offset always swung 50 degrees unless I babysat it, so I tried hanging a scrap piece of sheet metal inside the firebox door to deflect the airflow. It sounds goofy but it held 250 for 3 hours straight at a cookout in Austin last weekend. Has anyone else rigged up a simple baffle like that?

1 comments

hunt.rowan•22d ago

Almost ruined a brisket after a grease fire in my kettle at 2am

I was doing an overnight cook in my backyard in Tulsa, temp held at 225 for 6 hours, then I opened the lid to spritz and the whole drip tray went up. Grease had pooled under the deflector and a fat chunk fell right on the coals, flames shot up past the grates. I panicked and slammed the lid shut, cut all the vents off, and let it choke out for 20 minutes. The brisket picked up a heavy smoke soot taste, but I trimmed the bark off and it was still edible. Anyone else had a flare-up like this and saved the meat, or is it just ruined once that happens?

2 comments

dylan_green58•23d ago

Spent 40 minutes fighting a brisket wrap before realizing my foil was backwards

Dude I was standing there in Austin wrestling with a roll of heavy duty foil that kept tearing every time I tried to seal up the packer, then my buddy walks over and just flips the roll around and it works instantly. Anyone else ever get stuck on something so dumb in the middle of a cook that you almost called it a loss?

1 comments

anthony127•26d ago

Had a BBQ epiphany at a random gas station in Alabama

I was driving through Montgomery last month and stopped at a little gas station with a smoker out back. The old guy running it let me watch him prep his briskets, and he showed me how he trims the fat cap down to exactly a quarter inch instead of leaving it thick like I always did. Turns out I was wasting hours of cook time by leaving too much fat on, and my bark was never setting right because of it. Has anyone else changed their trimming method after seeing how a real pitmaster does it?

2 comments

loganhart•29d ago

Compared apple wood to hickory on my last brisket and it was night and day

I usually use hickory for everything but figured I'd try apple wood on a $80 brisket last weekend in Austin. The smoke flavor was way milder and the bark didn't set right even after 12 hours of cooking. Has anyone else had better luck with a specific wood for brisket over others?

1 comments

jessicamiller•1mo ago

Pro tip: Stop over-trimming your brisket before cooking

I kept seeing folks at my local comp in Kansas City shaving off every bit of fat cap, leaving barely a quarter inch. My first two briskets came out dry until I left a solid half inch on and let it render down slow. Have you noticed a big difference in moisture when you adjust your trim?

1 comments

palmer.henry•1mo ago

Swapped from hickory to pecan for my last brisket cook and wow what a difference

I've been using hickory for years on all my briskets but decided to try pecan on a whim last Sunday. The smoke flavor came out way smoother and sweeter without that heavy bacon vibe hickory gives. My neighbor Dave who usually just grabs a plate to be polite actually asked for a second slice and said it was the best brisket I've made. Anyone else made the switch and noticed a big change like that?

2 comments

ninas70•1mo ago

That cheap charcoal starter ruined my brisket cook

I grabbed a $12 chimney starter from a hardware store in Tulsa because my Weber one finally rusted through. After three attempts, it still wouldn't get the coals ashed over evenly, and my 15-pound brisket sat there at 180 for five hours before I gave up. Anyone else dealt with a dud starter costing them a whole cook?

2 comments

mason.paige•1mo ago

Talked to an old pitmaster at a gas station in Kansas City last Tuesday

I stopped for gas off I-70 and this older guy saw my smoker in the truck bed. He asked what I was running and I said a cheap offset from Walmart. He laughed and told me to go grab a roll of high temp gasket tape from a hardware store for 8 bucks. Said it would fix my temp swings better than any mod I could buy online. I did it last Saturday and my fire held at 250 for almost 4 hours without touching it. You ever get a random tip from a stranger that just worked way better than you expected?

2 comments

valwest•1mo ago

$40 for a wireless meat thermometer, best money I ever spent on my offset smoker

I got tired of babysitting my Lang 36 for hours on end so I bought one of those ThermoPro twin probe setups for like $40 on Amazon. Honestly I was skeptical because my old wired probe always gave out after a few cooks. But this thing let me actually sit inside and watch football while my brisket chugged along at 250. The wifi range is solid too, I can go out to the garage and it still connects. Only downside is the batteries die faster than I expected, maybe every 5 or 6 cooks. Anyone else switch to wireless and never look back?

2 comments

lisa_murray•1mo ago

Talked to an old pitmaster at a gas station in Kansas City last Tuesday

I was grabbing ice for my cooler and this older guy sees my BBQ team shirt. He starts talking about how he ran a BBQ joint for 40 years but never used an offset smoker. Said he cooked everything on a concrete block pit he built himself. It made me think about how much gear we obsess over when the basics might be all you really need. Have any of you cooked on something super simple that turned out amazing?

1 comments

paige870•1mo ago

TIL that old pitmaster at a competition in Memphis called me out for basting too much

I was at a BBQ competition in Memphis last fall, my first real one. I had this brisket I was trying to impress everyone with, and I kept opening the smoker every 20 minutes to baste it with butter and apple juice. This older guy, must have been 70, walked over from the next pit and just shook his head. He said "you're steaming that thing, not smoking it. Every time you open the door, you let out all the heat and stall it out." He told me to just let it ride for 3 hours straight without touching it. I felt stupid but I tried his advice. That brisket turned out way better with a real bark and not that soggy mess I was making. Has anyone else had an old timer call them out at a competition?

2 comments

craig.parker•1mo ago

Spent 2 years using the wrong wood for brisket and never knew

I've been smoking brisket for about 2 years now in my backyard here in Kansas City. Always used hickory because that's what my dad used and I thought that was the only way. Last week I ran out and grabbed some post oak from a local supplier on a whim. First bite of that brisket practically slapped me in the face with how much better the flavor was. Has anyone else had that moment where you realized you've been doing something basic wrong the whole time?

2 comments

carr.willow•1mo ago

I was sure pellet grills were a waste of money until last month

I spent 15 years as a stick burner purist, the kind of guy who gets up at 4am to feed a fire all day. My buddy Mike from the Memphis in May competition circuit kept telling me to try his Traeger for a brisket. I laughed at him every time for about 2 years straight. Finally, after my shoulder gave out from splitting wood, I caved and borrowed his pit for a Sunday cook. I put on a 14 pound prime packer at 10pm, went to bed, and woke up to a perfect 203 degree internal temp with no babysitting. The bark wasn't as crunchy as my offset, but the smoke ring was deep and the meat was moist all the way through. Now I'm looking at used pellet smokers on Facebook Marketplace this week. Has anyone else switched from stick to pellets and regretted it or felt like they sold out?

2 comments

alex_coleman•1mo ago

Took me 6 hours to figure out why my brisket bark was too soft.

I thought it was my rub or my fire, but it turned out my smoker's airflow was blocked by creosote buildup. That cleaning sesh took forever and I still missed the family dinner. Anyone else get blindsided by something dumb like that?

2 comments

craig.parker•1mo ago

The whole '30 minute bark rule' is overrated nonsense

I was at a competition in Kansas City last June and overheard this guy telling his team that if you don't get good bark in the first 30 minutes you've failed. I've been running a pit for 12 years and that's just not true. My best brisket took a full 45 minutes to set its bark at 225 degrees and it won second place at a county fair. Has anyone else had good results with a slower bark formation?

2 comments

alice_reed47•1mo ago

Just hit 100 briskets on my offset smoker and finally stopped being scared of the stall

Took me about 2 years and a bunch of dried out flats to get there, but last weekend I cooked a 12 pounder that came out perfect with zero wrapping. Has anyone else hit a number that made them feel like they actually knew what they were doing?

2 comments

alex_coleman•1mo ago

PSA: Watched a pitmaster in Lockhart Texas wrap brisket in butcher paper instead of foil

I was at Kreuz Market last month and saw they use pink butcher paper for the stall, so I tried it on my last cook and the bark stayed way crunchier. Is butcher paper actually better for holding bark or was it just a lucky fluke?

2 comments

johnson.lee•1mo ago

Switched from hickory to pecan wood after a buddy brought his own smoke to a cookout... never going back

I was always a hickory guy. Thought that was the only real way to smoke ribs. Then my neighbor Jim showed up at our July 4th block party with a St. Louis rack done over straight pecan. The color was this deep reddish brown and the flavor was way more mellow, not that heavy bacon taste you get with hickory. I tried it myself on a 8 pound butt last weekend and the family actually noticed the difference. Has anyone else switched woods and felt like an idiot for not trying sooner?

2 comments