Loading…

Had a talk with a 12 year old about Goku vs Saitama and it got deep | Anime Discussions - HW Forums

Had a talk with a 12 year old about Goku vs Saitama and it got deep

I was at my cousin's birthday party last Saturday and this kid, maybe 12 years old, came up to me and asked who would win in a fight between Goku and Saitama. I gave him the usual answer, saying Saitama's whole thing is winning in one punch so it's not really a fair comparison. But then he looked at me serious and said, "But Goku trains every day and never gives up, Saitama just got lucky with his workout. Who really earned their strength?" I honestly didn't know how to answer that. It made me rethink how I look at characters who are just born powerful versus ones who grind. Now I'm watching One Punch Man again with a totally different perspective. Has anyone else had a kid drop some anime wisdom on them like that?

2 comments

2 Comments

schmidt.grant4mo ago

I mean it's just a cartoon about a balding guy punching things, I think you're overthinking this a bit.

noahs824mo ago

And I just read about this exact thing in a manga analysis blog last week. They mentioned how Saitama's depression actually makes his strength feel hollow, like he skipped the journey part of becoming strong and now he's stuck at the end with nothing to work for. Goku on the other hand keeps finding new mountains to climb and new ways to push himself, so even though he's already a god, he still gets that satisfaction from earning his gains every arc. That kid actually has a point about who earned their strength more, because Saitama's whole story is about how being at the top without struggle is lonely and pointless. It makes you wonder if the real answer isn't about who wins in a fight, but who actually has the better life because of their power. Does that change how you see One Punch Man's whole theme now?