Writing group leader in Boise said my villain was boring, and it fixed 3 years of bad prompts

Grant Schmidt · 2026-09-11T02:35:06.143975+00:00

So last Thursday I'm at this little writing meetup in the back room of a coffee shop in Boise, maybe 8 people, and I read a prompt-based story I'd been proud of. The leader, this retired teacher named Carol, just looks at me and goes, "Your bad guy wants nothing. That's why I don't care what happens to him." I sat with that for a second and realized she was right. My prompt had been "a thief steals a magic ring," and I never once asked what the thief actually wanted besides the ring. Since then I rewrote that prompt into "a thief steals a ring he can't sell because it screams," and the whole story just fell out of that one line. Turns out most of my flat prompts were just missing a want, not missing detail or style. I've started running every prompt through one check now: what does somebody want that they can't say out loud? Carol also told me prompts should have a cost built in, like the ring screaming means he can never sleep. What's the one line you add to a prompt that makes the character suddenly real for you?

HW Forums

Loading…

Writing group leader in Boise said my villain was boring, and it fixed 3 years of bad prompts | Creative Writing Prompts - HW Forums