Picked Gloomhaven over buying a second copy of Spirit Island, and my Tuesday group of 4 just hit session 11
We voted 3 to 1 to run Gloomhaven for the campaign instead of replaying Spirit Island, and now we're 11 sessions deep with a running joke about the guy who always plays the Scoundrel opening the wrong door, so what's the longest you've stuck with one campaign before your group bailed?